Month: January 2023

When most of us think about the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), we think about a government agency designed to ensure public companies provide investors with accurate information, that employees who have access to “inside information” don’t trade on it, and that investment professionals don’t exploit, misinform or defraud the average investor on Main Street, USA. We certainly don’t think of the SEC as a means for broadly regulating private companies trying to raise capital, especially during a down economy many think is heading into recession.

President Ronald Reagan famously answered his rhetorical question of what are the nine most terrifying words in the English language as: “I’m from the government, and I’m here to help.” While we can take that notion with a grain of salt, the truth of the matter is that the SEC is one of the most powerful government agencies you may know the least about, and under current leadership, it is seeking a dramatic increase in its oversight, regulatory demands, and enforcement among all American companies, including, more and more, privately held ones.

The Great Depression spawned the SEC

The SEC was created by Congress in the wake of the Great Depression through the passage of the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. In a nutshell, one of the reasons for the stock market crash of 1929 was public companies providing false and misleading information to investors. In order to restore public confidence in the securities markets, Congress created the SEC with a mandate to ensure that companies made truthful statements, and that brokers, dealers, and exchanges treated investors honestly and fairly.

The SEC is considered an independent agency, which means that while it is part of the executive branch, it has regulatory and rulemaking authority outside of presidential control. This is largely because the president’s ability to dismiss the agency head or a commissioner is limited. The SEC can also bring civil enforcement actions seeking injunctions to prevent future violations and civil monetary penalties and disgorgement of illegal profits. The SEC cannot bring criminal actions, but does work closely with the Justice Department in support of criminal enforcement or securities violations.

The SEC is also meant to be bipartisan, requiring three of its five commissioners to be from one party and two from the other. Commissioners are appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate. SEC rules or regulations have the same power as federal law. Other similar independent agencies include the Central Intelligence Agency, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.

Private companies survive and thrive on debt

For privately held companies, small or large, access to debt is one of the key drivers of growth and is critical to effectively running a business. For decades, surveys have identified access to capital as the number one concern of American business owners.

Many private companies would prefer to secure capital through debt instead of equity investments for a couple of reasons. First, most business owners do not want to dilute their ownership in the business they founded or give up management control of the entity unless absolutely necessary. Second, and related, investors do not want to provide equity investments in companies, small or large, that may not scale adequately or quickly enough for a significant return on investment, or in ones where they would have little to no control.

Therefore, private companies often look for debt instruments from lines of credit or loans from their bank, SBA loans, crowdfunding debt, or by issuing debt securities also known as bonds. It is this last type of debt that the SEC has decided to regulate without much reason or by soliciting feedback from the public as it typically does in the rulemaking process.

SEC seeks to regulate private company debt securities

How did the SEC accomplish this feat? They did so by taking a rule that was intended to protect investors trading in the over-the-counter securities market, also known as “pink sheets” or penny stocks, and deciding it also applied to this debt offered by private companies. The rule they used is 15c2-11, which came into effect in 1971 to protect investors from being bullied into purchasing worthless penny stocks from unscrupulous and nefarious cold callers pretending to be stock brokers. You can watch the movies Boiler Room or The Wolf of Wall Street to get a picture of this phenomenon.

In 2020 the SEC decided it needed to update Rule 15c2-11 to correspond with advances in technology that have changed how people invest. Many investors don’t even have landlines anymore to accept cold calls, but are participating in chat rooms in Reddit and other social media sites to make investment decisions—often poor ones. This signaled a need for change.

However, in a surprising move a year later, the SEC staff declared that the requirements of Rule 15c2-11 also applied to privately issued debt instruments, and in December 2021 the SEC affirmed this viewpoint. In addition, the SEC did not follow its typical rulemaking process where it provides time for public comments on the proposed change. On November 30, 2022, the SEC declared that enforcement of the new rule will go into effect in January 2025.

It is important to note that one of the main reasons companies stay private is that they don’t have to disclose their financial information to the public and incur the accounting and legal costs of doing so under SEC regulations. Rule 15c2-11 is an exception to SEC Rule 144A, which exempts private companies from making public financial filings like those companies that are publicly traded. Debt securities issued by private companies under Rule 144A can generally only be purchased by qualified institutional buyers (QIBs), which are institutions with over $100 million in assets under management.

The average investor on the street cannot purchase these securities. QIBs can request financial information from companies issuing this debt, but they are not forced to disclose it to the public at large. In addition, there is currently no proposed rule change to allow retail investors to purchase this debt. So, instead of following its mandate to protect investors, by changing this rule, the SEC could cause a chilling effect on private companies accessing capital during a volatile time in our economy.

Is the SEC overstepping its authority?

Whether you own a privately held business, work for a public company, or invest in the securities markets, you should be aware of the role the SEC plays in regulating these fundamental aspects of our economy, which is the strongest in the world.

The SEC is critical to transparent and fair markets, but that doesn’t mean it should overstep its authority. Certainly, placing the same disclosure requirements and regulatory burdens on private companies as on public ones is one area that should be monitored closely.